When I learned I would be attending the recent Ty Murray Invitational in Albuquerque, I asked my longtime friend, John Hightower, to tag along. Hightower took me up on the offer, but he said he could only stay for Saturday night's performance because he had to be back Monday on his job as the special education director in the West Texas town of Plainview.
My first thought was that Hightower's choice to attend only the second round sounded OK, but he probably would get more for his money had he also chosen to stay for the Sunday afternoon performance, which featured both a qualifying and a final round.
I was wrong. Dead wrong.
Hightower got an eyeful. And it just goes to show that it doesn't matter what performance a fan drops in on these days on the PBR's Built Ford Tough Series. Any show has the potential for an exciting outcome.
The March 29 performance had all the elements that have made the PBR a fan favorite, thanks to its innovative formats that are designed with the fan in mind.
Among the highlights were five riders turning scores in the 90s, including L.J. Jenkins, who went on to win the event. That's the bull riding equivalent of seeing five home runs in the first five innings of a major league baseball game.
Here's a look that the box score from that performance: 1 (tie), Chris Shivers (Jonesville, La.) 91.25 points on Page & Teague Bucking Bulls' Holy Moly, $2,340; and J.B. Mauney (Mooresville, N.C.) 91.25 on Page & Teague Bucking Bulls' Hustler, $2,340; 3, Brendon Clark (Morpeth, Australia) 90.5 on Page & Teague Bucking Bulls' Commotion; 4, L.J. Jenkins (Texico, N.M.) 90.25 on Page & Buck's Savage Shaker; (5) Dustin Elliott (North Platte, Neb.) 90 on Beutler & Son Rodeo Co.'s Deputy Sheriff.
And those kind of scores are not unusual for the PBR, which is having a banner season for high scores. Last year, 73 rides were scored in the 90s during the regular season and the World Finals, according to the organization's public relations department. This year, the cowboys eclipsed that total in Albuquerque and there still was half a season to go.
Needless to say, my buddy came away feeling he had gotten a big bang for his bucks.
"It was very exciting going that one night in the middle of the show," Hightower said. "It was exciting even without going to see the final round. I knew that the cowboys were riding to make the finals, even though the finals were the next day. They were still competing with all of their might."
For the record, fans witnessed only four scores in the 90s during the 60 rides in Sunday's performance -- one in the third round and three in the finals. The five 90-plus scores Saturday came in a span of 45 rides.
In addition to the high scores, the crowd was treated to a little suspense when judges went to instant replay monitors to make two different rulings. The first ruling worked in the favor of Clark, after he challenged judges on their initial ruling that he had been bucked off a split second before the buzzer. But the second ruling went against Travis Briscoe when judges said the young superstar's hand popped out of his rigging just before the eight-second count.
The PBR put in the instant replay in 2006. If a cowboy feels the judges might have made an incorrect call, he can ask for a review. Clark received the 90.5 after judges determined he made the buzzer. But Briscoe was denied a possible score in the 90s after judges took a hard look at the ride.
Randy Bernard, the PBR's chief executive officer, said the instant replay gets fans involved.
"I watch crowds a lot and I see fans intensely watching the instant replay, and they are betting back and forth with their buddies whether the rider made it or didn't make it," Bernard said. "To me, that's creating coffee-shop talk for Monday morning when fans can say they were there or they saw it on TV. They might say, 'Oh, what a bad call!'"
Another element that has added to the drama has been the draft, a new format that allows riders to select the bulls they will ride in the second and final rounds. The PBR added the draft at the beginning of the season in an attempt to increase the percentage of riders who complete rides, generate higher scores and create a buzz among fans.
The PBR uses the draft only at three-day shows on the Built Ford Tough Series. Going into the second round, the top picks are based on the highest score and stay-on time in the first round. And going into the finals, the rider with the highest cumulative score gets the first pick in the draft.
Fans are invited to watch the riders pick their second-round bulls at the host hotel earlier in the day. In Albuquerque, about 200 fans watched the Saturday morning draft at the Sandia Resort and Casino.
"The draft has been so much fun for the fans because they get to know the personalities of the riders," said Cody Lambert, the PBR's longtime livestock and a founding father. "The riders seem to enjoy it, too. They're all good bulls to pick from. There are some bulls that the cowboys had rather pick and some that they had rather stay away from."
After winning the first round, Jenkins had the first pick and selected Savage Shaker, a very rank bull that helped him score in the 90s earlier in the season in St. Louis.
"Savage Shaker was my No. 1 pick for a bull today," Jenkins said after his ride. "I knew I could make a 90-point ride on him so I decided to go for it."
That's the type of exhilarating action that fans buy tickets to see. And here are some questions on PBR shows for fans:
1. If you have attended an unusually outstanding performance that wasn't a final round, what happened to make it a memorable experience?
2. What do you think about the influx of 90-point rides this season?
3. Do you think that the instant replay system adds drama to a performance?
4. Do you think that the draft is making the sport more compelling?
5. What type of innovative moves should PBR organizers add to make the performances more compelling for fans?
My first suggestion for events would be more info on the bull scores.
When my wife and I attended our first event live (Sacramento just this year) we kept looking for the bull scores and individual Judges breakdown of rider and bull - just like on TV.
We really missed that info in the arena.
Thanks, Don
I don't think the draft makes the sport more compelling.This is bull riding.If anything the draft gives an unfair advantage to certain riders.You pick your bulls in a practice pen.This is the big leagues and it should be the luck of the draw.As for the statements made tha t riders try harder if they are not giving 100% every round then they sure don't belong on the BFTS tour.In recent weeks the draft has not seemed to have payed off too well for the riders. This is bull riding; and that in itself is pure adrenaline rush.To think you have to add to it to make it more "compelling" is ridiculous! Riders vs bulls is all that's needed. Fans are constantly complaining about all the "extras" They want to see the rides.that is the draw. Its why more and more bull riding associations are growing up all over the country.The action in itself is the top draw.Lower ticket prices and give family discounts to draw more in during this recession.When it comes to the broadcast the fans keep crying they want more rides and get rid of the camera following riders out back; and less talk! Oh and how about giving all the scores as some do get missed due to too much chatter. Go back to the best bulls instead of a lot of rerides. You don't have to improve on the most popular part of rodeo.
tapered off. When you play PBR Fantasy that is more important to a fan than Bull Teams. Those scores matter then and we end up having to wait till the next day to get them. I do like the draft, it seems to be working out fairly well. As long as rides arn't cut out on broadcasts. Something has made a few be cut, don't give us a broadcast like NBC coverage.
we arn't seeing.
I am new to the sport, so I assume many of the high scores come from smarter bull breeding and use of video equipment that helps riders learn from previous rides to improve their performance.
I think the instant replay is invaluable. In this sport, money is at stake on a wrong call, like in horse racing, and we have to do what is humanly possible to get it right. In baseball, it isn't a big deal, the team gets paid, the season goes on, but in bull riding, it's the difference between a paycheck and no paycheck. That adds enough drama for me.
The draft is interesting as the PBR tries to make the cowboys become "personalities" like sports stars, and so understanding their process and business decisions with regard to bull choice does add an element of interest. I wouldn't overstate it, though, because some of the riders seem to make pretty random choices, or don't care to know much, and I respect that point of view. In some ways, the less known the better because it keeps them from having false expectations about the bull they get.
In terms of what type of innovative moves should PBR organizers add to make the performances more compelling for fans, please keep the information consistent! Post a bull score on a buck off, show the breakdown of the score at a live event between bull and rider, don't let Versus ad banners for cover the information so that if a viewer glances down for a second it's too late, and for pete's sake (and I realize this is my one person's opinion), I could live without the bull teams. The team/bull/contractor names all start to blur in my mind, and there is so much clutter on the broadcasts now that it sometimes precludes live, compelling action. Oh, and I totally agree about the camera following the cowboys--it makes me uncomfortable to watch and I think they deserve privacy to react after a disappointment.
1. If you have attended an unusually outstanding performance that wasn't a final round, what happened to make it a memorable experience?
Answer:
In the 4-5 live events that I've attended, I think the most outstanding and memorable performance that was outside of a championship round was made by the bull Dr Proctor. First time I saw this bull at an event. I think this may have been his second season bucking at the PBR level. My god that bull was airborne and spinning! Of course the rider was bucked. It was the most memorable event for me. Dr. Proctor still amazes me to this day although he doesn't have the exact same fervor he had when I saw him a few years back.
2. What do you think about the influx of 90-point rides this season?
Answer:
A 90 pt ride doesn't seem to difficult to achieve this year. I think it's all about the judges and how much they want to promote the newer bulls and the ABS.
3. Do you think that the instant replay system adds drama to a performance?
Answer:
Yes, the replay system keeps the judges honest as well as the riders. There will always be technical difficulties such as the silly clock that sometimes never goes off, or goes off too soon. Also adds drama for re-ride option purposes. When a rider hits that challenge button you know something is going to go down... Either the judges call is going to be overridden or the rider is going home with 500.00 less in his pocket!
4. Do you think that the draft is making the sport more compelling?
Answer:
I absolutely love the draft. I think it challenges the riders to really do their homework on Bulls. The match ups are always better then what the computer usually draws. It's always fun to see who is going to take the most rankest bulls on the list and why they selected the bull..
5. What type of innovative moves should PBR organizers add to make the performances more compelling for fans?
Answer:
Put more focus on the bulls and not so much on the riders. I think they should have an event Bull Profile. Bring down the lights in the , bring the bull that is chosen out to the event pen and focus the spotlight on him as he is allowed to trot around the arena. Play a video about the bull on the large arena screens with his ride highlights, information about his record, and his home life off the road and on the ranch. Or, since they always introduce all 45 riders with much fanfare, they should at least allow the 15 short go bulls to be introduced and allow each of them to run once around the pen :) That would definitely make my 100.00 ticket worth while! I'm not sure if the stock contractors would be crazy about this idea, but I think the fans would love it! I know I would!
Ok now, I'm a woman, your probably thinking what do I know...but I am a hard core PBR fan and to this day none of my family or friends will ever understand how I can be.. They think it's funny... not to mention odd...:)
I am going to be very honest. I am a teenage girl. I'm about halfway between being a city slicker & a cowgirl. I didn't grow up on rodeo. I got into PBR 'cause I got SICK of hearing my friends talk about Lord of the Rings. I would pull out a pic of say Chris Shivers or Justin McBride & say "He's cuter & does his own stunts." Watching one ride after another gets boring to me. Watching one wreck after another gets gross. These guys are about the only celebrities I like. I wanna see personality.
Maybe you don't agree with me, but I am part of who PBR is trying to appeal to-& it is working. When Mike Lee gets bucked off, I wanna throw something-HARD!
I don't think that PBR can ever please EVERYONE-that's impossible. But they do seem to be trying hard.